The New York hotel that I zeroed in on, three decades ago, when we were poor grad students, was the Helmsley Palace. It’s attached to the historic Villard Houses, which I’d read about in Paul Goldberger’s book on New York architecture. Dating from 1884, the houses were modeled on a Renaissance palazzo in Rome. Six adjoining brownstone townhouses surround a central courtyard, giving the effect of one large, grand mansion. The first project of the architectural firm McKim, Mead & White, the compound was built for Henry Villard, a former journalist and president of the Northern Pacific Railway. The location is Madison Avenue, directly across from St. Patrick’s Cathedral.
During the 1970s, the developer Harry Helmsley acquired the air rights to the Villard Houses and made plans for a fifty-story hotel atop the compound. Preservationists raised the alarm after hearing that Helmsley intended to demolish large portions of the historic buildings. Plans were modified, and the developer agreed to preserve most of the townhouses, including their interiors.
I saw glimpses of these lavish interiors in commercials for the hotel during the 1980s. The ads showed Harry’s second wife Leona Helmsley posed imperiously atop the central stairway, flanked by subservient staff. The tagline was “The Helmsley Palace, Where the Queen Stands Guard.” Leona may have considered herself the Grande Dame of her husband’s hotel empire, but thanks to her bullying, demanding behavior, her employees dubbed her the Queen of Mean. Having remarked that “only the little people pay taxes,” Leona later went to prison for tax evasion.
My interest in the Palace Hotel had nothing to do with Leona Helmsley, and everything do with the beautifully preserved, gilded-age interiors of the Villard Houses.
I can’t recall the details that went into my booking what I thought was a night at the Helmsley Palace. I must have caught wind of some pre-Christmas discount, because money was short in those days.
What I can’t forget, though, was that we arrived in New York from Princeton in the midst of a significant nor’easter. I hadn’t heard that weather term before, and I’d certainly not experienced it. My husband and I quickly learned that a nor’easter, especially in December, is not a pleasant time for leisurely, big-city sight-seeing. The winds howled without cease, exacerbated by the tunnels created by the tall buildings. A frigid mix of sleet, snow and rain swirled around us, pelting our faces. The streets of Manhattan appeared to be littered with hulking black birds in their death throes, as useless, abandoned umbrellas flapped in the breeze. I can’t remember what we wore, but I know we were not appropriately dressed for such dire weather. My husband didn’t have a hat. I had a scarf, but it was quickly soaked, giving the effect of wearing an ice pack outdoors in winter.
Why did we not cancel? Most such details, fortunately, are hazy. Probably because I’d already paid. Probably because we thought, “Oh, how bad can it be?”
It might have been worth braving the terrible weather if we had only been able to find shelter at last in that sought-after destination, the Helmsley Palace.
But no. Somehow, I’d booked our stay not at the Helmsley Palace, but at the New York Helmsley. I can’t remember when or how we discovered the mistake. Did I realize the error before our departure? Or did we go to the Palace at Madison and 51st, only to be turned away? To be sent back out into the icy winds and make our sad way over to 3rd Avenue and 42nd?
The New York Helmsley (now the Westin New York Grand Central) was, and is, no dive. Its 40-story tower was constructed in 1981, a bland rectangular block similar to that at the Palace. But its lobby was, to me, a dull, forgettable, contemporary space, and a huge disappointment when I was expecting the time-tested opulence of the Villard rooms at the Palace.
Our room was perfectly fine, definitely the nicest I’d ever entered in New York at that point. It was a vast improvement over the youth hostels and threadbare accommodations I’d been used to in my low-budget student travel in Europe. There were two windows, and an actual view. Not an especially good view, out onto a gloomy, windswept 42nd Street, but also not onto an air shaft.
My mother likes to tell the story of a Manhattan hotel room she and my father stayed in when they were young and newly married. In the adjoining bathroom, the tub appeared to have been cut in half by a wall. That was one surprise, at least, that we did not encounter during our trip.
We stayed only one night, which was a blessing. A two-night visit was beyond our means. The next day, a Saturday, the bad weather persisted. I had hoped we’d enjoy cheery lights and shop windows adorned for Christmas, but I recall no such festive sights. I assume we took refuge in a museum or two. But we walked the icy streets long enough to be very uncomfortable. We went into one of the hundreds of Sbarros in Manhattan to try to warm up. The door, oddly, had been open, and we closed it when we entered. One of the employees rushed out immediately from the kitchen to close it again. Really? I rarely cry, but that day I put my head down on the cheap laminate table and sobbed. My husband, shocked at my unseemly display, appealed to the employees, who were overheated because of their work near the pizza oven. H promised the young men that we wouldn’t be long. We’d eat our slices, thaw out a little, and be on our way. They allowed him to close the door.
We probably headed back to Penn Station shortly after we emerged from the Sbarro. After two days of enduring New York in a nor’easter, it felt like luxury, for once, to settle ourselves onto those ugly orange seats in a shabby New Jersey Transit train.
We finally managed a weekend stay act the actual Palace Hotel in 2010. We’ve returned there a few times since. This past October, we had planned a weekend get-away at what is now known as the Lotte New York Palace. A nor’easter was predicted to coincide with our visit. This time, with the wisdom that comes with age and experience, we postponed for a week.





































































